考えと株式市場の変動:過去70年からの新たな実証結果

というNBER論文が上がっている(ungated(SSRN)版)。原題は「Beliefs and Stock Market Fluctuations: New Evidence from the Past Seven Decades」で、著者はDavid Thesmar(MIT)、Emil Verner(同)。
以下はその要旨。

We construct a new long-run series of subjective expected equity returns from an independent equity analysis firm, spanning 1956-2024. These expected returns are strongly positively correlated with the earnings-price ratio, respond negatively to past returns, and predict future returns. These patterns contrast with subjective expectations of individual investors and professional forecasters, which are weakly or negatively correlated with our new measure. Disagreement between sophisticated and individual investors is associated with higher trading volume. Our findings are consistent with a model of heterogeneous beliefs, where naive investors extrapolate past returns, rather than past dividends, while sophisticated investors are close to rational.
(拙訳)
我々は、独立系株式分析企業から、1956-2024年に亘る主観的な予想株式投資収益率の長期時系列を構築した。この予想収益率は益回りと強く正に相関しており、過去の収益率に負の反応を示し、将来の収益率を予測する。このパターンは、我々の新たな指標と弱いもしくは負の相関を示している個人投資家と予測専門家の主観予想と対照的である。洗練された投資家と個人投資家の間の意見の違いは、出来高の多さと関連している*1。我々の発見は、ナイーブな投資家が過去の配当ではなく過去の収益率を外挿する一方、洗練された投資家がほぼ合理的である、不均一な考えのモデルと整合的である。

株式リターンの予想データの長期時系列を入手した株式分析企業はValue Line(Value Line - Wikipedia)とのこと。

*1:これらの点について本文では「We provide four main findings. First, VL’s expectations of returns are very different from the expectations of other investors. The beliefs of VL and individual investors are weakly or even negatively correlated, depending on the survey. Second, VL expected returns are contrarian and account for most of the fluctuations in the earnings-price ratio, in a manner consistent with rational econometric benchmarks. This contrasts with the expectations of individual investors, whom we find extrapolate past returns, though not past cash flows. Third, VL expected returns predict future realized returns. Finally, greater disagreement about expected returns between VL and individual investors is associated with increased trading volume and volatility. Our findings highlight the importance of sophisticated investors and heterogeneous beliefs for understanding stock market fluctuations.」「We further show that VL expected returns are negatively correlated with past returns, consistent with countercyclical expectations of returns. In contrast, expected returns from other professional forecasters are essentially uncorrelated with past realized returns, and expected returns of individuals tend to be positively correlated with past realized returns, as documented in the literature on extrapolative beliefs (e.g., Greenwood and Shleifer, 2014). 」と記述している(Greenwood and Shleifer, 2014はExpectations of Returns and Expected Returns | Andrei Shleifer)。